Lucille "Lucy" Thatcher

Owen was wrongly convicted of murdering Molly Baker; the real killer, Simon Keller, let Owen take the blame, and Owen was killed by other prisoners before Garrick could prove his innocence. Caleb Voss hands Lucy the gun; she kills Keller herself.

Follower #5 — the fifth and final follower, who stays with Garrick to the end and volunteers to become the Horror's host at Ashfall Ridge, believing she can give Garrick the restoration he lost with Bran. Garrick tries and fails to stop her. At Ashfall he finally calls her "Lucy" — her family name — right before the Horror swats him aside.